It’s been a while since I have posted a Labor Law Movie Review and watching 9 to 5 is not something that will make me jump at the chance to do these more regularly. A little too over the top campy for my tastes, but it does provide some interesting historical perspective. The film was released in 1980 and depicts a workplace that gives hostile environments of today a good name. The plot is actually pretty detailed but here are the basics (Warning – Spoilers):
The film is centered on three women who work in the offices of Consolidated, a company in Chicago. Judy (Jane Fonda) is a new employee whose husband recently left her. Violet (Lily Tomlin) is the supervisor of her department and a longtime employee of Consolidated; she has been passed over repeatedly for promotions. The boss, Franklin Hart (Dabney Coleman), is a sexist monster. The third woman is Doralee (Dolly Parton), Hart's personal secretary. Although Doralee is married, Hart continually makes lewd advances. Hart also tells co-workers that he's been having an affair with Doralee, making her the topic of office gossip. When Violet complains to Hart that he passed her over for a promotion because she is a woman, Hart tells her that the company would rather have a man in the position. Doralee learns that everyone thinks she is having an affair with Hart and Judy witnesses a co-worker lose her job over a minor issue. As a result, all three women are angry at Hart. Through a series of improbable events, the trio kidnap Hart and hold him in his own house while they run the department their way with positive results. Of course, everything works out in the end and Hart gets his comeuppance.
The workplace depicted in 9 to 5 is so over the top that it does not really lend itself to an analysis under today’s employment laws. In fact, the most interesting aspect of the movie is the absence of employment law as factor in the workplace. Recall that Title VII was passed in 1964 and prohibited discrimination on the basis of gender. However, it was not until 1986 that the Supreme Court decided Meritor Savings Bank v. Vinson, recognizing sexual harassment as a violation of Title VII and establishing the severe or pervasive test that is so familiar today. Thus, when 9 to 5 was filmed, sexual harassment litigation was uncommon if not unheard of by most people. If nothing else, the current obsession with resolving workplace disputes in the courts avoids the need to self help remedies, such as the one contemplated by Doralee early in the movie:
Look, I've got a gun out there in my purse. Up until now I've been forgivin' and forgettin' because of the way I was brought up, but I'll tell you one thing. If you ever say another word about me or make another indecent proposal, I'm gonna get that gun of mine, and I'm gonna change you from a rooster to a hen with one shot! And don't think I can't do it.
Also of interest are the changes made by the women while they are holding the boss hostage. Many of their improvements are things that actually came to pass, e.g. job sharing and flex time. I give this movie high marks for labor law content since it is all about the workplace but there is no legal accuracy to evaluate since the law is simply not part of the story.
Finally, the theme song is catchy but the lyrics read like a socialist tract:
It's a rich mans game
No matter what they call it
And you spend your life
Puttin’ money in his wallet
Great – now it’s stuck in my head.
Labor Law Content **** (out of five)
Labor Law Accuracy N/A (out of five)
As always, I welcome your comments. You'll find a link to my email address at the CONTACT line below.
Topics/Tags
Select- Labor & Employment Law
- Non-Compete Agreements
- Employment Law
- Coronavirus
- Labor Law
- Federal Trade Commission
- Department of Labor
- National Labor Relations Board
- Wage & Hour
- Privacy
- Reasonable Accommodation
- Pregnancy Discrimination
- NLRB
- Workplace Accommodations
- FMLA
- Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation
- Employment Litigation
- Arbitration
- Workplace Violence
- Discrimination
- Religion Discrimination
- Medical Marijuana
- FLSA
- IRS
- Litigation
- Social Media
- Employer Policies
- Americans with Disabilities Act
- Disability Discrimination
- Medical Cannabis Dispensaries
- Retirement
- National Labor Relations Act
- Race Discrimination
- Sexual Orientation Discrimination
- Accommodation
- OSHA
- Whistleblower
- Employer Handbook
- ERISA
- United States Supreme Court
- EEOC
- ADAAA
- ACA
- Affordable Car Act
- Unions
- Title VII
- Employer Rules
- Sexual Harassment
- Technology
- Federal Arbitration Act
- NLRA
- Transgender Issues
- Disability
- 401(k)
- Employment Settlement Agreements
- Sixth Circuit
- Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
- Fair Labor Standards Act
- Paycheck Protection Program
- Benefits
- Class Action Litigation
- Disability Law
- Gender Identity Discrimination
- Posting Requirements
- Securities Law
- E-Discovery
- Evidence
- Health Savings Account
- Preventive Care Benefits
- SECURE Act
- US Department of Labor Employee Benefits Security Administration
- Family and Medical Leave Act
- Environmental Law
- Privacy Laws
- Overtime Pay
- Representative Election Regulations
- Department of Justice
- Healthcare Reform
- Older Workers' Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA)
- Electronically Stored Information
- Telecommuting
- Affirmative Action
- Compensable Time
- Equal Opportunity Clause
- Security Screening
- Supreme Court
- E-Discovery Case Law
- Electronic Data Discovery
- ESI
- Occupational Safety and Health Administration
- Return to Work
- Seniority Rights
- Unemployment Insurance Integrity Act
- American Medical Association
- Attendance Policy
- Classification
- Confidentiality
- Equal Pay
- Fair Minimum Wage
- Federal Minimum Wage
- Genetic Information Discrimination
- Media Policy
- Misclassification
- National Origin Discrimination
- Retaliation
- State Minimum Wage
- Wage Increase
- Disability Leave
- Social Media Content
- Employment Incentives
- HIRE Act
- Social Security Tax
- Taxation
- Antitrust
Recent Posts
- NLRB General Counsel Expands Focus on Non-Compete Agreements and Stay-Or-Pay Agreements
- FTC's Non-Compete Rule Struck Down
- District Court Finds in Favor of FTC, Declines to Issue Injunction
- DOL Increases Compensation Threshold for Exemption Eligibility
- Federal Trade Commission Announces New Rule Invalidating Non-Compete Agreements
- EEOC Announces Final Rule Providing Guidelines under the PWFA
- The Practical Employment Law Podcast: Immediate Termination
- The Practical Employment Law Podcast: Labor & Employment Law Update February 2024
- The Practical Employment Law Podcast: Telephone Game
- The Practical Employment Law Podcast: Labor & Employment Law Update January 2024