In an ERISA case pending in the Northern District of Illinois involving breach of fiduciary duty and prohibited transaction claims, the plaintiffs filed a motion asking the court to allow them to proceed in a representative capacity on behalf of the plan under ERISA section 502(a)(2) rather than require them to certify a class under Federal Rule 23. The District Court in Chicago denied that motion based on the defendants' opposition, and suggested that the case proceed, not as a class action under Federal Rule 23, but as a "derivative action" under Federal Rule 23.1.
On an issue of first impression, the Court adopted our argument that the plan — in this case an ESOP — was the real "party in interest," and as such, the plaintiffs are effectively bringing their claims derivatively on behalf of the plan. See Fish v. Greatbanc Trust Co., et al., ___ F. Supp. 2d ____, 2009 WL 3649814. As a result, the court concluded that there was "no need for the parties to jump through the procedural hoops required for Rule 23 class certification" and suggested that Rule 23.1 may provide a more efficient means to "bind all Plan participants to the holdings ultimately reached by this Court." We will be putting on a stipulation to that effect shortly.
If you practice in ERISA class action litigation (like we do), the Fish approach may be an alternative to the "class or no class" debate.
Article reprinted from Westlaw with permission of Thomson Reuters. If you wish to check the currency of this case you may do so by using KeyCite on Westlaw at www.westlaw.com.
- Partner
Mike Scheier is a trial lawyer who also helps our clients manage their litigation risks and achieve cost-effective non-litigation solutions. His practice is concentrated on valuation and shareholder disputes, and in the defense ...
Blog Contact: Joseph Callow, Litigation Partner
jcallow@kmklaw.com or 513.579.6419
Topics/Tags
Select- Coronavirus
- Class Action Litigation
- Litigation
- Cybersecurity and Privacy Law
- Data Breach
- Securities Law
- Supreme Court
- E-Discovery
- Intellectual Property
- Social Media
- Trademark
- Trademark Litigation
- Sixth Circuit
- Initial Coin Offering
- Antitrust
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure
- Bet-the-Company Litigation
- E-Discovery Case Law
- Electronic Data Discovery
- Employment Law
- Workplace Accommodations
- ESI
- GDPR
- General Data Protection Regulation
- Employer Policies
- Labor & Employment Law
- Labor Law
- SEC
- Cryptocurrency
- Securities Litigation
- Technology
- ERISA
- Stock Drop
- Ascertainability
- Cybersecurity Regulation
- Drug Enforcement Agency
- Medical Marijuana
- Ohio Foreclosure Reform
- Craft Brewing
- Copyright Law
- Seventh Circuit
- Environmental Law
- Fair Housing Act
- Health Care Act
- Healthcare Reform
- Pregnancy Discrimination
- Religion Discrimination
- Electronically Stored Information
- FLSA
- Proportionality
- Accommodation
- Americans with Disabilities Act
- Cyber Insurance
- EEOC
- Telecommuting
- Business Process Improvement
- Employment Litigation
- Lenders
- Receivership Statute
- Employer Handbook
- Employer Rules
- National Labor Relations Act
- National Labor Relations Board
- NLRB
- Unions
- E-Discovery Project Plan
- Evidence
- Predictive Coding
- TAR ( Technology Assisted Review)
- Quality Representation
- Subpoena
- Arbitration
- CAFA
- Land Use & Zoning
- Construction Litigation
- Privacy
- Statute of Limitations
- Taxation
- Federal Rule
Recent Posts
- Questioning the Questionnaires: New PPP-Related Litigation Raises Issues for Borrowers
- "You Don't Have to Go Home But You Can't Stay Here": Updates to Ohio and Kentucky’s COVID-19 Orders Impacting Bars & Restaurants
- Kentucky Restaurants Begin Opening with Limited Capacity Amid COVID-19 Epidemic
- Ohio Restaurants and Bars Begin Soft Openings for Diners Amid COVID-19 Epidemic
- Supreme Court Sidesteps “Cy Pres” Challenge
- Golfers, New and Old - Be Careful!
- "Aloha Poke": Social Media and Consumer Perception are Part of the Trademark Enforcement Equation
- GDPR: Less Than 100 Day and Counting to "G-Day" - Here's What You Need to Know
- Rapid SEC Action Against AriseBank Reveals New Playbook For Allegedly Fraudulent ICOs
- Giga Watt ICO Faces Tezos-like Securities Litigation Challenge